Overview
Chapter 239 §8A permits certain defences/counterclaims in possession cases for nonpayment or termination without tenant fault. Follow court payment orders and the final balance deadline; the separate Chapter 186 §19 rule is not identical to every housing right.
Why is this needed?
Separating notice, repair and court conditions helps avoid an invalid deduction, termination or underpayment.
Key requirements
- When the landlord learned of the condition, arrears start date, cause, occupancy type/duration and court notices.
What to do
Check knowledge before arrears
For a condition-based §8A defence, the owner, agent or rent collector must have known BEFORE arrears arose. Proof that you or a person under your control caused it affects the defence; where the area is solely under your control and not naturally connected to the landlord, you bear the burden of proving the condition was not caused by you or a person under your control.
Distinguish accommodation and vacancy exceptions
This condition defence excludes hotels/motels and lodging/rooming-house occupancy of less than 3 consecutive months. A separate limitation applies if the landlord proves remedy requires vacancy, but temporary vacancy for lead-paint removal/covering does not create that bar. Statutory evidentiary presumptions apply to serious code violations and official inspection reports; provide your dated report.
Follow interim court payment orders
Where the conditions are met, possession cannot be recovered before final disposition; this does not permit ignoring court payment orders. After a hearing the court may require fair use/occupancy payments or escrow net of eligible claims, and may use funds for repair or appoint a receiver. Voluntary escrow after the action begins is also possible.
Do not miss 1 week after the final balance notice
If your award equals or exceeds the landlord’s, possession is not awarded under this section. If the landlord has a net balance, paying the clerk that balance, interest and costs less applicable prior payments within 1 week after the court’s WRITTEN balance notice may prevent recovery of possession. Do not calculate this deadline from a rent date or oral conversation.
Bound the separate unsafe-condition injury rule
Chapter 186 §19, excluding owner-occupied 2- or 3-family premises, addresses reasonable-care correction within a reasonable time after tenant registered/certified written unsafe-condition notice and a tort claim for resulting injury. Tenant/consenting-occupant-caused conditions are excluded. Your notice is unnecessary for a portion outside your control, and an official code-violation notice suffices. Do not extend this section’s building exclusion to §8A or every habitability right; residential waiver of §19 is void.
Official sources
- General Laws chapter239 §8A – Defences and counterclaimsmalegislature.gov
Relevant conditions and procedure.
- General Laws chapter186 §19 – Unsafe conditionsmalegislature.gov
Relevant conditions and procedure.
- General Laws chapter111 §127L – Tenant repair remediesmalegislature.gov
Relevant conditions and procedure.
General information only. Not a substitute for personal legal, financial or medical advice.